Read: 1 Corinthians 3:16, Ephesians 2:10, 3 John 1:2. If you want to decorate your pious judgement up with scripture, thats your call. There may be a link from that to the post. She is giving a message of hope is she? Keep in mind, these ladies are only parroting what they heard from Dr. Carolyn Leaf! The truth allows for real hope. As for the haters and the vitriol it comes with the territory. As for your question about what Im offering? Ive laid out the truth in a rigorous and defensible way. 2 Timothy 1:7 And in her book Switch on your brain [1], she said on page 33, For now, rest in the assurance that what God has empowered you to do with your mind is more powerful and effective than any medication, any threat, any sickness, or any neurological challenge. Maybe it was just coincidence that I was reading Dr Leafs book at the time but I believe if we use Holy Spirit discernment when reading books/articles or listening to people (regardless of their correctness) God can protect us. She teaches that thoughts cause stress, when again, the evidence is the opposite psychological stress starts as a subconscious process which changes our stream of thoughts. She was not making exegetical statements about scripture, rather conclusions based on scientific study in relation to how God designed us. Something comes up or I get distracted but I see it as a way of God protecting me. Her own fundamental philosophies contradict each other. Dr. Caroline Leaf 3y A Conversation with Bishop T.D. With over thirty years in research and study, she delves into Cleaning Up Your Mental Mess with these five simple steps to help reduce our anxieties, stress, and toxic thinking. At the same time, you do seem to support it, and proclaimed it Sunday by reiterating that we had this speaker at the church. Here is a link defining the dangers of this teaching: http://www.gotquestions.org/religious-science.html You can think whatever you like about me or my brand. During this time, Dr. Any use of this information is at the users discretion. Data collection happens within the app every 21 days for the 20 LMM items and the 8 pro-mindfulness factors as well as a web-based survey (psychdata.com) for user demographics, treatment history, and program experience. First, understand the triggers and signals for toxic thoughtsthink critically about when, how, and why those thoughts arise. 1:7). Whats Wrong With Dr. Caroline Leafs Theology Freedom of speech is an important principle and I want to allow it as much as possible, especially since Dr Leaf deletes all vaguely negative comments and blocks those who leave them. My analogy here is not to suggest that Dr Leaf is deliberately conning the church. The information offered in Dr. And, if we detox our thoughts, we will be restored to the health that God intended. . I wanted to understand what you were saying but I never saw anything written to back up your arguments. Its a mirage, a manipulation of messaging and social media. You can read the introduction to my book on Dr Leaf here: http://www.debunkingdrleaf.com/new-page it is a more in-depth discussion on my work and its context. Yes. Thank you so much for being a vessel of The Lord and standing in truth. Its certainly a unique window into the human psyche that one doesnt tend to see in other parts of life, so in some ways its a privilege to be sledged as I am from time to time. So while Dr Leaf may claim that her research has changed the learning and lives of thousands of students all over the world, but her own published research disputes her claims. Otherwise, a lot of people might find themselves disappointed- which apparently is what most people in her audience are trying to avoid, hence the general curiosity in the quest for this knowledge. Leaf Mind Management (LMM) Scale Validation. 0801093600. Thank you, but no apologies are necessary. The hundreds of scientific articles that Ive quoted would counter your position, but you dont seem to be bothered by cognitive dissonance, so I doubt youll be adjusting your narrative. Caroline Leaf may be a qualified "cognitive neuroscientist with a PhD in Communication Pathology specializing in Neuropsychology". I didnt want negative images or words to influence their minds. In the end, Im going to write what I write in the best way I find to write it. The data collection protocol begins with an email invitation, and non-responders are contacted up to three times by email reminders spaced by 5-7 days each. You are going to activate a miracle in your life. Critics and sceptics love to use any opportunity they can to embarrass the church, but by parading our own naivety, were simply embarrassing ourselves. Dr. Caroline Leaf is the author of Switch On Your Brain, Think and Eat Yourself Smart, and The Perfect You, amongst many other books and journal articles.Since 1981, she has researched the science of thought and the mind-brain connection as it relates to thinking, learning, renewing the mind, gifting, and potential. In her books, on TV, at churches, and in promotional material, Dr Leaf describes herself as a cognitive neuroscientist. (Unpublished manuscriptcopyright protected Baker Publishing Group) Dr. Caroline Leaf, Switch on Your Brain Baker Books, a division of Baker Publishing Group, 2017. I know people personally with mental illness, and scitsophrenia. That is beside the point. I am also of course, interested in any correction you have to offer me. Learn how your comment data is processed. The data will be used to identify needs and priorities, benchmark against various population characteristics, evaluate programs and policies, plan for services and programs, and advocate for resources. A number of people from different churches the world over have told me that following Dr Leafs sermons, the pastors have had to provide a type of disclaimer because of Dr Leafs extreme views regarding the management of mental illness. Paul is simply saying that through the Holy Spirit, we have all the tools: power, love and the control to use them, so we dont have to be afraid. If your church leaders cant show that Dr Leafs teachings are scientifically and scripturally accurate, then politely ask them why shes been invited to preach from their pulpit or to sell her wares in your church? It helped me a lot, but I think that it worked for me because of the active reach you did every day for 7 times. This, in itself is delightful and, intriguing because, as you work out your gift and find out who you are, you will be developing your soul and spirit. (Emphasis added), This quote in and of itself isnt actually that significant until we compare it to a quote from the first chapter of Dr Leafs 2013 book, Switch on your brain. [1], The first argument proposes that thoughts come from your brain as though your brain is generating all aspects of your mental experience. I would have stopped reading at your exclamatory sentence that Quantum physics prove me thoughts can control matter except that there was nothing more to read, since you didnt bother to actually justify your opinion. Data is analyzed by an independent research and analysis consulting firm, Elite Research, LLC (www.eliteresearch.com). Imagine you are kneeling at the feet of God. She also quoted James 1:15 interpreting it as our toxic thinking leads us to death. However I must admit that something from her book did help God give me a huge aha revelation that has plagued me all of my life. The plans of our sovereign Lord rarely align with our plans, and if we proceed as though they are we will end up off course. He is not glad to see you enjoy yourself, and his pressing invitation is empty verbiage with no heart in it. (http://goo.gl/nvSYUh). Leaf has been studying what happens to our brain cells when we think. More of Dr Caroline Leaf - - - Oh, be so blessed! Hold That Thought: Reappraising the work of Dr Caroline Leaf. Ive recently been going through one of the deepest, longest periods of depression Ive had for the last few years, and its just as unpleasant as the last time. I dont want to nitpick what he or she said or didnt say. Leaf also says,As we think, we change the physical nature of our brain. Dr Leaf also makes claims about her research and achievements that arent backed up by her published papers. Change you behaviour from praise to worship. Jakes on Mental Health, Spirituality & Racism + How He Deals with Anxiety Dr. Caroline Leaf 3y Much of this work is highlighted in her books and we are currently in development of a historical timeline outlining these applied projects and their results to showcase Dr. Leafs historical research on the website. A critique, on the other hand, is a detailed analysis and assessment of something, especially a literary, philosophical, or political theory. Critique is how ideas are tested and knowledge grows. When they were little and something scary or inappropriate came on, I would voice it. So many of my active reaches were actual scripture or biblical concepts. So, you may have to write it down in your calendar and tell yourself that your strong habit will be established on, say, October 20. I have my PhD is Leadership Studies so I know first hand the work that goes into earning a PhD. and biblical insight, Dr. Caroline Leaf empowers readers to take control of their thoughts in order to take control of their lives. God gave us a brain, its appropriate that we actually use it. Dr. KCM Broadcast Notes April 17-21 2023 - The Christian Chain of Command. For more information about Dr. Leaf's teachings see below. Watch Believer's Voice of Victory as Kenneth Copeland discusses how the Christian chain of command serves one another. If you have a medical matter or emergency, please contact a local medical professional immediately. Pray: As I lay down my head, I know you help me rest deeply. She is a communication pathologist and cognitive neuroscientist specializing in cognitive and metacognitive neuropsychology. [3] Hunter PR, MacDonald AM, Carter RC. 8. But there are cracks appearing. Dare I ask you do you know the difference between academic critiquing and vexatious criticisim? 50 years ago people just died! God, please continue to remind me and open my eyes to your deep love for me. I thought go back to the detoxing work of Dr Leaf. Take for example, the treatment of depression. One of Dr Leafs most fundamental assertions is that 75 to 98 percent of mental and physical illness comes from ones thought life [1]. She is a neuroscientist talking about the power of the brain and mind. Her influence continues to grow. Again, its up to you if you want to believe the PR narrative of Dr Leafs selfless perfection, but its a facade. My greater concern is that we are once again addressing this topic of healing. I speak life to my immune system. Many people ask why an alternative view is needed.Why criticise Dr Leaf? as well as Dr Caroline Leaf's clinical experience and research, you will learn how thoughts impact our spirit, soul, and body. You will protect my mind and my thoughts as I drift off to sleep. She must have her facts straight if she is preaching at some of the biggest churches on the planet, right? You can find her on GodUpdates, iBelieve, Crosswalk, Hello Darling, Focus On The Family, and in Brio Magazine. She also misquotes her sources, significantly changing the meaning of the quotes in the process. I agree with this person, PH. Reggie McNeal Reiling Rev Dr Stephen Robinson Reverend Bill Crews Rev HN Bate Rhona Davies R H . Thanks for your comment. ""Is it even Biblical to publicly speak against an anointed leader?, The answer is simple:1. This is interesting: http://www.abideinchrist.com/messages/2cor3v18.html. Hopefully theyll be less inclined to recommend it to their other patients. Thank you for your open-minded interest in discovering the truth. I agree wholeheartedly. [1] Leaf, Uys, and Louw. Since 1981, Dr. Caroline Leaf has researched the human brain with particular emphasis on unlocking its vast, untapped potential. Dr. Caroline Leafs career as an applied neuroscientist spans clinical, education, field research, and government contract experience. March 16, 2015. Dr Caroline Leaf is a communication pathologist, world renowned author, public speaker, and self-titled cognitive neuroscientist. I believe ________________ Church owes their followers a reasonable teaching on this issue, and a correction! She has endorsements from Joyce Meyer, Bobbie Houston, and a number of other pre-eminent Christian pastors. Leaf was recently on Janet Parshalls show. I might be wrong, but this is how it comes across and this does make it harder for me to read it with an open heart and mind. When considered in the historical and global context [2], most of human illness is related to preventable diseases that are so rare in the modern western world because of generations of high quality public health and medical care. Dr. Caroline Leaf is a communication pathologist and cognitive neuroscientist whose passion is to help people see the power of the mind to change the brain and find their purpose in life. This is part of the Jeremiah 17:9 problem. Midwives, vaccinations, pap smears, clean drinking water and internal plumbing have nothing to do with our individual thought life. Emerging infectious diseases 2013 Aug;19(8):1192-7. Also, see Job 1:12. We take all of this for granted in the first-world, so the impact of our thought life becomes artificially inflated. We are co-creators of our destiny alongside God. We choose whether we want the enemy to rip us apart by our actions, which is caused by and further creates mental health issues. As I think about this one, it was Satan who asked Gods permission to afflict Job. Our thought life either builds us up or tears us down in more ways than we ever imagined. Access a growing selection of included Audible Originals, audiobooks and podcasts. Leaf. The scripture is clear on this: You do not have a spirit of fear but of love, power and a sound mind (2 Tim 1:7)., Simply checking the verse in its full context, and in a different translation, shows it in a completely different light to the way Dr Leaf promotes it. However, I would hope you would discuss it with Pastors _____ or _____, and I would like to hear from them. [9] Zysset S, Huber O, Ferstl E, von Cramon DY. Throughout this time, Dr. Im willing to engage in robust discussion especially when people are overtly hostile, and allow me to pre-emptively state that youre welcome to your opinion on that too. Dr. A culmination of her life's work, Dr, Caroline Leaf's Think, Learn, Succeed book combines current scientific research with biblical teaching to show how each person has the power to improve their creativity, intelligence, and emotional health. I appreciate that youve considered all sides and are looking for the best in both. Publisher. I say this with all due respect. Anyone who thinks on anything that many times during a period od 63 days will see a change in things. I used to have an old school mindset about it and thought it was a frame of mind, which it is most definitely NOT. Brisbane, Australia: Pitt Medical Trust, 2014. If you are considering withdrawing from any medication, please do so under the guidance of a professional as withdrawal can be a dangerous process. If you want to discuss in detail I suggest setting up a meeting. I1 have been such a huge fan of hers but truthfully I have somehow managed to not be able to complete her book Switch On Your Brain (had it for 5 years)1 successfully. So whats with the second half of the verse? Then my kids would close their eyes tight and put their little hands over their ears. She developed the Geodesic Learning theory and the metacognitive-mapping approach (how we think and process information), which has been shown to increase thinking, behavioral and academic performance by 35-75%. 637=441. Dr Leaf teaches that in order to improve our mental and physical health, we need to fight any negative or toxic thoughts, when studies show that cognitive therapy isnt effective when compared to behavioural activation. I now clearly see why you have written your book. I was referring to the post, in and of itself, where you made statements and didnt say why or from where the information came. Lesion mapping of cognitive control and value-based decision making in the prefrontal cortex. If the habit is well established, it can take as long as 3 sets of 21 or 63 days to remove a bad habit completely. In my saying it didnt seem like you were being nice, I was referring to the comments made to Laci just a few posts ago wherein you said, my guess is that if you stopped reading one of my blog posts as soon as something challenged your exceedingly shallow world view, then you wont even click on the link. That just didnt seem to be too nice. In more scientific terms, genes are not self-emergent. Our God is Sovereign and healing is His prerogative by believing Prayer. C) the redemptive power of the resurrection d) our addiction to sin and the fight of Spirit and Flesh E) Sin leads to death(unrepentant heart) F) her blasphemous mouth at comparing the majesty of our Triune God to NewAge magical thinking G)The power we have tin Christ is by His power in us- not power in and of ourselves;as if its some energy field we slingshot over to Africa as if we are little gods H)Fear is real, but those of us in Christ havent been given a spirit of fear Quantitative Electroencephalography (QEEG) Assessment of the NeurocycleTM. i think you need to understand that Dr Leaf is first and foremost a christian,and her approach to her field is from scriptures.. The data collection protocol begins with an email invitation, and non-responders are contacted up to three times by email reminders spaced by 5-7 days each. Leave the toxic issue at His feet. Leaf began developing her Neurocycle and Metacog system for mind management. Withoutcritique of scientific theories and findings, we would still be living in mud huts as hunter-gatherers. Thanks for thinking about it and approaching with an open heart and mind. Data is analyzed by an independent research and analysis consulting firm, Elite Research, LLC (, The study will provide a detailed picture of changes in mindfulness, mind management skills, and mental-health-related issues in adult populations. God leads, but we have to choose to let God lead. All the best to you. Matthew 6:27 27 And which of you by worrying can add a single . How is one supposed to know what is good if no critique is offered, if only one position is provided? Go have a good hot cup of tea with Dr Leaf and bury the hatchet which you keep flaying around. The other question that Im asked is why I even need to critique Dr Leafs work at all? A critical step for improving mental health is developing non-pharmacological therapies that can treat anxiety and depression effectively without reliance on pharmacological treatments and the accompanying risks for side effects and interactions. Please discuss specific symptoms and medical conditions with your doctor. I ALMOST referenced her in a paper I am writing for my English class. To facilitate non-pharmacological therapy for mental health, individuals require specific knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors that promote self-regulation skills and increased awareness, processing, reconceptualization, and control of reactions and responses to the circumstances of life that cause feelings of anxiety and depression. Leaf'steamis not allowed publish theirresearch findings ahead of the peer reviewed journal article, here is some information on theircurrent research. Dr Leaf believes that our thinking can influence our DNA. 75 98% of current mental, physical emotional illnesses today come from our thought life. Its also in the blog posts and answers that Ive given to the same question over the years. She is regularly invited to speak at some of the world's largest churches. We must be vigilant! Joyce Meyer for example teaches that positive affirmations change or impact reality, denying Gods sovereignty or giving us creating power equal to God?? Your brain simply captures what your mind dictates. Leaf's books and materials are intended to serve as guidelines for managing toxic thoughts, emotions, and bodies and not as a replacement for professional medical advice. Dr Caroline Leaf Still Contradicted by the Latest Evidence, Scripture and Herself. The theory proposes that everything you say and do is first a physical thought in the physical brain, a thought which you built with your mind. 6:10-11) and be aware of the lies and deception thats creeping into the church and twisting the Truth. Leaf operationalized her knowledge of neuropsychology in decades of government contracts with South African departments of education and clinical patient work. KCM Broadcast Notes April 10-14 2023 - God's Miracle-Working WORD. General; Old Testament . Feel free to share your experiences in the comments section. I am happy to drop the issue, as I have said everything, do not feel I have more to say on it and am satisfied with your reply. To learn more about Dr. Depression is hard, and I appreciate the empathy. They receive messages from other brain cells. All rights reserved. That can change to alollipop within 14 days. Dr Caroline Leaf 21 Day Brain Detox How To Detox Webstudies, Dr. Caroline Leaf provides a scientifically proven five-step plan to find and eliminate the root of anxiety, depression, and intrusive thoughts in your life so you can experience dramatically improved mental and physical health. NOTE: This is NOT a substitute. I diligently worked her program daily for 1 1/2 years. Dr. Caroline Leaf is a brilliant and prolific communication pathologist and cognitive neuroscientist. Okay thank you for posting a different view on this subject. Jesus announced: The good person out of the good treasure of his heart produces good, and the evil person out of his evil treasure produces evil, for out of the abundance of the heart his mouth speaks. Such an assertion is ludicrous, and science proves it to be so the still small voice comes from our brains [8-10], and everyday office-based medical tests prove that the electromagnetic signal from the heart is too small to have any meaningful influence on our bodys cells, let alone our thinking [7: Ch 11]. Consider this, from Dr. Caroline Leafs book Who Switched Off My Brain: Research shows that around 87% of illnesses can be attributed to our thought life, and approximately 13% to diet, genetics and environment. Most of the information from this article was taken fromthe video below. Ill make my own choices led by The Holy Spirit who guides us in all Truth. I appreciate and respect your beneficent and diplomatic approach, and while I generally agree with your stance, I do not think it should apply to Dr Leafs teachings. A specialist in traumatic brain injuries and learning disabilities, she has worked in the area of cognitive neuroscience since 198. Im offering the truth. An individual rain drop has no power on its own, but when it combines with millions of others, it becomes a force of nature, shaping the world! Her assertions about her title and the results of her work are in conflict with her own official data. These toxic emotions can cause migraines, hypertension, strokes, cancer, skin problems, diabetes, infections, and allergies, just to name a few.. Implementing the LMM through the NeurocycleTM app, the findings of Study 2 found that test-retest reliability for all six LMM subscales was strong and that construct validity existed with established anxiety, depression, and well-being measures. The mind is what the brain does, they believe, and the ramifications are significant. I will add that today was day six of my wife not taking her meds, and we spent the day figuring out how to get her back on them, as she is now experiencing the consequence of six days without meds. Required fields are marked *. Dr Leaf has simply been misquoting it for years, and no one checked to see if shes right. All the very best. Be a servant of Love! Perhaps you could give us that evidence, otherwise its just hear-say. I dont have connections or church networks who invite me to speak at churches worldwide. Not only do they suppress free speech, they also actively block anyone who dares to be anything less than sycophantic towards Dr Leafs ministry. Again, I have had a number of people recount their issues with Dr Leaf and her teaching people with very legitimate mental illnesses who have been directly affected by following Dr Leafs advice, or indirectly affected because their church has been convinced by Dr Leafs teaching that mental illness is the result of toxic thinking, and as a result, failed to give appropriate support to those who are the most vulnerable and most in need of support. The primary aim of these trials is to make mental health care more affordable, applicable, and accessible worldwide, and to reduce the stigma around mental health. Must pray without ceasing, but we dont have to beg. Much of this work is highlighted in her books and we are currently in development of a historical timeline outlining these applied projects and their results to showcase Dr. Leafs historical research on the website. Here's exactly how to do it, below: Step 1: Gather. But this isnt just getting some minor facts wrong. See 1 Corinthians 13:10-12. Therefore what medical science has just proven is that most of the time, disease is a consequence of sin - particularly in our thought life. Isnt this persistent attack on Ms Leaf a bit pass Mr Pitt? Our wisdom defines our capacity to access His goodness. Youre welcome to agree with Dr Leaf if you want to, but please dont pretend that your agreement based on your own life experiences is science. She isnt the only doctor exploring healing mindsets. Its there in black and white. It seems that youve fallen for Dr Leafs humanistic Sci-Fi fantasy version of egocentrism which she claims to be quantum physics. Dr. Leafs passion for improving mental health and learning led her to focus her early career in clinical and community settings to get her program to as many people as possible. I am just wondering, if Dr Leafs teachings are wrong, what would you suggest to people who are suffering from mental illness that they should do? Or maybe something like and in the middle of the arena are the Christians and shortly well see the lions making an entrance. Bible Study with Dr. Caroline Leaf Posted by Les'a Cole On July 22, 2016 0 Comment Join us for this brain-transforming Bible Study: Thursdays 1-2:30pm. Finally, a quick word on critique and criticism. Thank you very much for explaining to me further. On the first day of a set of 21 days cup your hands & ask the Holy Spirit what toxic thought you should work on. In academic circles, Dr Leafs research hasnt so much as generated a stale whimper [14]. Its only when enough people have stood up for the truth that those in authority will finally take heed and listen. The app had a large amount of cliches.. What I can do in this limited space is to outline Dr Leafs most egregious and ironic fallacies as a taster. I hope youre out of your cloud of depression, or are almost there, and I wish you all the best for your journey of understanding into psychology. However, her statement is completely wrong. Really? As they got older, that same phrase also encompassed a new aspect about their thought life with the verse, Be careful how you think; your life is shaped by your thoughts, (Proverbs 4:23 GNT). I understand where youre coming from. Thats certainly a lot more than most, and Im always grateful for those that do. Withoutcritique of scientific theories and findings, we would still be living in mud huts as hunter-gatherers. It is a very insightful review. This was confirmed in the psychosocial assessments conducted alongside the QEEG tests, which revealed a corresponding improvement in decreased toxic thoughts, isolation, and overall LMM score as well as increased autonomy, awareness, empowerment, life satisfaction, and ability to manage life obstacles. I stayed with it and they finally got an app that worked. Where is your faith? She has more than 120,000 Facebook followers, with many more on Twitter and other social media platforms. Managingtoxic thoughts and trauma through the5-step Neurocycle process, 5. Luke 10:20. Dr Caroline Leaf | SpiritMindBody Connection NEW!!! For a month I tried to work the program which was quite different from the detoxing one. She was one of the first in her field to study how the brain can change (neuroplasticity) with directed mind input. When we focus on the negative, chemicals are released in our brains causing damage like loss of sleep, physical illness, or the inability to perform your job appropriately.
Amb Referral To Hematology,
Winter H2b Extension 2022,
Laurie Crouch Health,
Lucid Motors Stock Forecast 2030,
Articles I