No one expected the Inquirer to undo the influence of generations of structural racism in a few months. News values revisited (again), The media and the mayors race: The failure of urban political reporting, The watchdog still barks: How accountability reporting evolved for the digital age, Local journalism and the information needs of local communities: Toward a scalable assessment approach, Funding democracy: Public media and democratic health in 33 countries, Capital and control: Consequences of different forms of newspaper ownership, International Journal on Media Management, Democracy without journalism? Shifting a newsroom toward antiracism has less to do with ensuring that individual journalists are not personally racist than it does with interrogating the influence of structural racism on newsroom systems and processes. Final search string for COVID-19 coverage: (headline=(covid* OR coronavirus* OR pandemic* OR vaccin* OR virus* OR Wuhan OR Hubei OR CDC* OR quarantin*) OR lead=(covid* OR coronavirus* OR pandemic* OR vaccin* OR virus* OR Wuhan OR Hubei OR CDC* OR quarantin*)) NOT (headline=(Eagles OR Flyers OR Phillies OR Sixers OR 76ers OR NCAA OR MLB OR NHL OR MLS OR NFL OR soccer federation OR minor league OR major league OR happy valley OR PSU OR golf OR soccer OR football OR Penn Relays OR Owls OR auto racing OR NASCAR) OR lead=(Eagles OR Flyers OR Phillies OR Sixers OR 76ers OR NCAA OR MLB OR NHL OR MLS OR NFL OR soccer federation OR minor league OR major league OR happy valley OR PSU OR golf OR soccer OR football OR Penn Relays OR Owls OR auto racing OR NASCAR) OR obituaries OR sound off OR letters to the editor OR clarifications OR clearing the record OR Dear Abby), ((police said OR police spokesperson OR detectives said OR investigators said OR authorities said OR according to investigators OR according to police OR according to the police OR prosecutors said OR was charged with OR is charged with OR arrested and charged or was accused of OR is accused of or was arrested for or on charges of or cops id or police id) OR headline=(stabbing* OR stabbed OR aggravated assault OR assault* OR murder* OR manslaughter OR rape* OR robbery OR robbed OR killer OR attacker OR shooting* OR gunshot OR gun shot OR knife or burglar* OR vandal* OR detectives OR embezzle* OR theft OR stole* OR slain OR homicide* OR felon* OR misdemeanor*)) NOT ((Eagles OR Flyers OR Phillies OR Sixers OR 76ers OR NCAA OR MLB OR NHL OR MLS OR NFL OR soccer federation OR drown* OR thunderstorm OR tornado OR house fire OR sound off OR college basketball OR letters to the editor OR police brutality OR Black Lives Matter OR George Floyd OR Breonna Taylor OR Daunte Wright OR Rayshard Brooks OR Daniel Prude OR Walter Wallace OR clarifications OR legislat* OR editorial OR live life love OR politics OR sports OR Dear Abby OR capitol OR tear gas OR *plane crash OR President Trump OR Donald Trump) OR headline=(coronavirus OR covid OR virus OR vaccin*)), Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. Major television affiliates for ABC, CBS, NBC, and Fox also wield significant journalistic resources, but data on the composition of their audiences are unavailable. After its infamous 'Buildings Matter, Too' headline, the paper launched its 'Inquirer for All' project to rebuild to be . Apologies were issued, a change in newsroom leadership was announced, earnest Additionally, Harcup and ONeill (2001) identify the magnitude of an event as a key news value, as with a pandemic that affects very many people in many ways. Excluding their ratios, Philadelphias media system has a weighted average ratio of 4.8 (3.9 excluding Jewish Exponent and Philadelphia Magazine, as well). Local TV news, where we would expect to find lower income and education indices (though we lack the data to produce these indices), does not appear to help close these gaps, as most COVID-to-crime news ratios at local TV affiliates are low, occasionally even negative. 2015 data for Al Da; all other data reported during period 2017 to 2020. But she was among the first to have that romance, with a powerful politician, blow up into a public scandal. (2006) to develop and validate search term strings that demonstrate high levels of precision in surfacing this coverage. (, Napoli P. M., Stonbely S., McCollough K., Renninger B. The Inquirer noted that when it asked how the review would work, how ballots and election equipment would be secured, who would be involved, and so on, the leaders of this effort did not explain. In the absence of quality local news, communities often turn to social media and less-reputable sources for critical local information, enabling misinformation and spectacle to proliferate. He was released in 1979, and he and Ms. Foreman were married in 1980. Dividing adjusted numbers of COVID-19 stories by adjusted numbers of crime stories generates a ratio of COVID-19 to crime coverage for each outlet. (2006), recall measures the degree to which a search string includes all relevant stories; precision measures the degree to which a search string includes only relevant stories. The AP set off to learn their identities. Unlike our assessment of average income, education, and age indices, ratio averages include major commercial TV affiliates, which generally have large audiences but low COVID-to-crime coverage ratios and thus have a systemwide suppression effect on average ratios. (2012) identify eight categories of such critical information needs: Emergencies and public safety; health; education; transportation; environment and planning; economic development; civic life; political life. Free to qualified media, marketing and advertising professionals. And it led the paper to adopt one of the first ethics policies in what was still a largely freewheeling, unprescribed profession. Ms. Foreman left for New Orleans in the 1990s. She went to The Times in January 1977, arriving in Washington with the new Carter administration. These gaps seem particularly pronounced when commercial outlets attempt to draw audiences with crime coverage that focuses on individual incidents rather than on the broader social and economic factors that fuel crime. There's a simple but powerful idea behind the Philadelphia Inquirer's recent decision not to use the word "audit" when referring to an effort by the state GOP to investigate the 2020 . Managers also shared that they were building community-engagement goals into the performance reviews of editors of several teams to encourage each to brainstorm and implement engagement ideas for their desks. The Afghan debacle lasted two decades. Or should news organizations employ clear thinking and plain language, intended to serve the publics understanding and interests? Broadcast jobs want you to sound like Walter Cronkite, but in a Black female body, says one news anchor. The latter may include subscriptions, corporate underwriting, or donor and foundation support, which may encourage news production that does not prioritize a communitys information needs (Benson, 2018; Browne, 2010). Acknowledgments: Thanks to Temple Universitys audit team and collaborators from The Philadelphia Inquirer for making this work possible. Our study, which builds and applies a multi-dimensional framework for analyzing local media systems, shows that news gaps can arise when some news outlets produce substantial coverage for some audiences while neglecting others and when they provide overall inadequate coverage of vitally important issues related to public health and other critical information needs. The newspaper asked her to resign eight months later over her conduct in her previous job, at The Philadelphia Inquirer. There was no obituary. It reports general news with a minimal bias, however, when it comes to opinion and editorial pieces, the left-center bias seeps through them. The Inquirer created an Anti-Racist Workflow Guide that offers a series of questions (e.g. Overcoming Joel Embiids absence, Sixers take Game 1, 119-115, behind James Hardens 45 points, Ed Snider Youth Hockey & Education, the Flyers, and Flyers Charities open new street hockey rink in Kensington, Police Commissioner Outlaw is back to full duty after she was injured in a car crash, Sixers head coach Doc Rivers reflects on his time in Boston, embraces new role as 'arch enemy'. Dear Abby | Son wants to meet someone but doesnt know where to look. He was a naval officer during World War II and in 1948 moved the family to Memphis, where he worked in public relations and advertising. @PatMcLoone is the very best boss I've ever had. Based on 2018 median HHI for Black/African-American majority Census tracts in Philadelphia (Shields & Siddique, 2020). As one manager explained, centering antiracism as a core value meant editors who were not on board with that would experience pain points that they hoped would spur shifts: Either you change or you opt out.. Media Kit; Contact Albk E., van Dalen A., Jebril N., de Vreese C. H. (, Althaus S. L., Cizmar A. M., Gimpel J. G. (, Ardia D, Ringel E, Ekstrand V. S., Fox A. For our content analysis generating ratios of COVID-19 coverage to crime coverage, we follow the rigorous method outlined by Stryker et al. Digital-only outlets included in Table2 are Billy Penn, Catholic Philly, Passyunk Post, Philly Voice, and West Philly Local. After a few months, she worked briefly at the A.P. Newsrooms need accessible standards about their use of AI to maintain trust with news consumers and ensure accountability of the press. I may have done something injudicious. Marketing Automotive Awards(April 5, 2023, NYC), Creative Media Awards(February 2, 2023, NYC), Agency of the Year(January 25, 2023, NYC), MediaPost All Stars(January 25, 2023, NYC), Lauren N. Williams Named Deputy Editor for Race at Guardian US, Musk Settles Defamation Case Over Claim Made In An Email, Former USA Today EIC Nicole Carroll To Launch Local News Initiative, Lee Enterprises Plans To Reduce Print To Three Days A Week: Report, Keep up-to-date with media, marketing and advertising news, Invitations to exclusive industry events and research. Laura Foreman, Reporter Whose Romance Became a Scandal, Dies at 76, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/23/business/media/laura-foreman-dead.html. A higher ratio indicates more coverage of COVID-19 vs. coverage of crime. Robert L. Mooney/The Philadelphia Inquirer. under pressure to appear patriotic in the aftermath of the attacks. Ms. Foreman, who at one point supervised a staff of about 20 people at Time-Life, also freelanced for Discovery Publishing, which produced illustrated books to accompany television specials, and for other publishers. Based on staff levels and audience size, the Philadelphia Inquirer arguably occupies a dominant position in the Philadelphia media system, though an online paywall at Inquirer.com limits access for non-subscribers. Nonetheless, the article noted, editors had examined her past work and had found it to be fair and accurate. MEDIA ACTION GUIDE Updated January 2019 TV STATIONS CBS 3 - Eyewitness News 1555 Hamilton Street Philadelphia, PA 19130 John Wilson, News Director Email - wilson@kyw.com Phone (215) 977-5333 Website www.cbsphilly.com Email - newsdesk@cbs3.com 6ABC WPVI-TV 4100 City Avenue Philadelphia, PA 19131 Tom Davis, News Director Phone (215) 878-9700 #21 Can foundations solve the journalism crisis? WCAU/NBC10, WPVI/ABC6, and WTXF/Fox29 figures based on multiplatform users in Philadelphia Inquirer (2018) media kit. Theres a simple but powerful idea behind the Philadelphia Inquirers recent decision not to use the word audit when referring to an effort by the state GOP to investigate the 2020 election: The words that a news organization chooses to tell a story make a difference. Congress may be about to help local news. We use this time period because several major Philadelphia outlets are archived in Factiva on a rolling, approximately 90-day window. A boat containing 14 bodies appeared in the Caribbean. These outlets are Catholic Philly; Delaware County Daily Times; Main Line Times; Northeast Times; Passyunk Post; Philadelphia Weekly; Willow Grove Guide; Roxborough Review; South Philly Review; University City Review and Philly Free Press; West Philly Local. Established a formal process that will allow certain types of stories to be rendered Research also suggests that Black audiences consume more television news and less Internet news than white audiences and that Latino audiences are less likely than white audiences to seek out news regardless of media format (Althaus & Tewksbury, 2007; Althaus et al., 2009; Bucy, 2001). They have power. include emergencies and public safety among their critical information needs, the authors note the negative impacts of reportage on crime, which can generate fear of crime and minorities in local communities, and they emphasize a communitys interest in fair and accurate representation (p. 11). Andrea Wenzel, Poynter. Significant transformation will mean pushing beyond the Inquirer for All as a project, and integrating its efforts into the ongoing work of journalism at the Inquirer. Ratios of COVID to Crime Items in Databases, published between May 11, 2021, and August 18, 2021. While Friedland et al. While some managers suggested that it was expected that talent would be poached because the Inquirer was no longer viewed by some as a destination newspaper, other staff suggested more needed to be done to create a working environment in which BIPOC journalists felt their life experiences were acknowledged and welcomed. Additionally, though we argue that during the pandemic a broader range of critical information needs are met by COVID coverage than by coverage of individual crime events, we acknowledge that the importance of COVID news versus crime news is an open question. Surveys of Philadelphia residents find that crime news is popular but that what residents desire the most is news and information of a highly personal nature that they can put to use in their day-to-day lives (Delli Carpini et al., 2018, p. 8). Based on 2018 median HHI for Hispanic majority Census tracts in Philadelphia (Shields & Siddique, 2020). It furthers the University's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide, This PDF is available to Subscribers Only. Our selection excludes New Jersey news outlets east of Philadelphia. Indeed, in Beaver County, Pennsylvania, news-starved residents turned to Facebook alerts for their news needs, which fueled the rapid spread of fear, exaggerations, and falsehoods (Zadrozny, 2021). Here's What It's Done in a Year, Net Neutrality: What You Need to Know Now, Where Does My Representative Stand on Net Neutrality, Where Does My Senator Stand on Net Neutrality, A Philadelphia Inquirer Headline Sparked Outrage and a Newsroom Audit. The Times confirmed her death through public records and with friends. These data sources include Editor & Publisher; BIA/Kelsey; ABYZ News Links; Micheles List; New Jersey Press Association; the National Newspaper Association; Onlinenewspapers.com; MondoTimes.com; and the Library of Congress. Staying in the Washington area, Ms. Foreman re-established herself at Time-Life Books. according to an affidavit obtained by the Philadelphia Inquirer. This includes the Delaware County Times, Metro (Philadelphia), and digital-only Philadelphia Patch, but not Philadelphia Tribune, which largely serves Philadelphias Black community. Media ownership and public service news: How strong are institutional logics? Primarily based on (a) data indicating prominence in terms of circulation, viewership, or web traffic, or (b) frequent mention in published articles as important outlets for news in Philadelphia, our final selection includes 38 outlets in the greater Philadelphia area,2 representing a mix of ownership types serving mass audiences and niche audiences. In subsequent years, the press used euphemisms like enhanced interrogation techniques when they should have said torture. Or they called suspected terrorists at Guantnamo Bay detainees, as if they were being sent to the principals office rather than serving what amounted to a prison term of many years. to spot and avoid cultural bias. One way the Inquirer is attempting this is by building DEI goals into their performance management system, particularly for editors. It also banned the widespread practice of accepting freebies from sources and others in their news coverage. That amounts to 23% of the 210 people who started 2021 in the newsroom. Findings indicate that Philadelphias news media system underserves communities with lower levels of income and education and that this structural gap generates a measurable gap in the provision of news content meeting the critical information needs of these communities. The conversations focused on crime and justice coverage with the hopes of informing the Inquirers newsroom guidelines and building relationships with impacted communities. RQ4: How do different forms of media ownership affect the provision of news coverage that meets communities critical information needs? Confronting the misinformation society, Uneasy peace: The great crime decline, the renewal of city life, and the next war of violence, Validation of database search terms for content analysis: The case of cancer news coverage, Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, Presentation and impact of market-driven journalism on sensationalism in global TV news, Community-centered journalism: Engaging people, exploring solutions, and building trust, Sourcing diversity, shifting culture: Building cultural competence in public media, Communication, class and concentric media practices: Developing a contemporary rubric. Declining advertising revenues associated with digitization have forced many newsrooms to cut staff or close entirely. In answering RQ4 concerning ownership impacts on critical information needs, we find that public-funded and nonprofit media produce more COVID-19 coverage relative to crime stories than their commercial counterparts. Subscribers-only sports, politics, restaurant reviews & more on Inquirer.com. Finally, they have held a series of four initial discussions connecting editors and reporters with community stakeholders, organized by the Shift the Narrative Coalition. A 2020 diversity audit found that the Philadelphia Inquirer, the dominant print and online news outlet in the citys media system, underrepresents people of color in its content and that its staff is overwhelmingly white (74.3% of newsroom staff; Monroe & Wenzel, 2021, p. 22). Finally, building an antiracist work culture requires management to hold employees accountable and to incentivize antiracist newsroom practices. He pleaded guilty, was sentenced to five years in federal prison and was out on parole after 27 months. the newsroom staff, met weekly in working groups in an effort to make the Inquirer an anti-racist news organization, Hughes adds. The Author(s) 2022. Who am I centering in this story?) for reporters, editors, and producers to consider at different points in the journalistic process. While they are continuing to hash out the best approach to integrate source tracking into their workflow, their stylebook audit is in progress, and they have already launched the Content Consult channel. Roughly 80 team members, more than one-third of Here's how to get from Philadelphia to the Jersey Shore by train, bus, rideshare, or, if you want to splurge, private jet. The EIN for the organization is 59-1630423. The Inquirer often covers crime against the backdrop of concerns over high homicide rates in Philadelphia. Our final, closed search string for crime stories achieved 91% precision and 87% recall. The Philadelphia Inquirer was published in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania and with 3,831,414 searchable pages from 1789-2023. A sub-headline makes it clear that this effort is modeled off the months-long partisan review in Arizona, widely regarded as irrevocably flawed and unnecessary to begin with, initiated by Republican lawmakers carrying water for Trump and placed in the hands of dubious private firms. And a number of them worked in the Twin Towers. They noted this was a valuable first step which they planned to follow up on. We reached out to Sarah Stonbely at Montclair State Universitys Center for Cooperative Media, who is leading an extensive mapping and content analysis of New Jerseys media system, which has some overlap with Philadelphia. Created an internal forum for journalists to seek guidance on potentially sensitive content and to make anti-racism central to their journalism. Our research questions are: RQ1: To what extent are socioeconomically and demographically differentiated (by income, education, and age) audiences served by Philadelphias media system? (, Ferree M. M., Gamson W. A., Gerhards J., Rucht D. (, Friedland L, Napoli P, Ognyanova K., Weil C. (, Napoli P. M, Stonbely S, McCollough K., Renninger B. This byline is mine, but I want my name removed. However, by emphasizing multiple, interacting dimensions of a media system and different production logics, Chadwicks approach suggests a framework for media system analysis that encompasses both the structural drivers of local news (audience socioeconomics; ownership structures), which influence media production (Benson etal, 2018; Napoli et al., 2015; Picard & van Weezel, 2008; Stonbely et al., 2019), and the different weight that individual outlets carry within a local media system (differences in audience size; digital-only vs. legacy outlets that combine print, broadcast and the Internet to various degrees). The Inquirer for Alls work also put it face-to-face with another 800-pound gorilla, namely journalism norms and traditions that have historically bolstered whiteness, including the dominant interpretation of objectivity as the view from nowhere. There was resistance from those who saw antiracism as activism that was antithetical to the rules of journalism. The Voice committee decided that if the Inquirer was to be an antiracist newsroom, it needed to outline what values guided their work as an antiracist newsroom, including acknowledging the role journalists play in their communities, and recognizing how journalists are informed by their own life experiences. For more by Margaret Sullivan visit wapo.st/sullivan, More than six months after the 2020 presidential election, Arizona Senate Republicans are leading an audit of the 2.1 million ballots cast in Maricopa County. Average unique monthly visitors for all outlets, except monthly page views for Philadelphia Citizen, University City Review, Philly Free Press, and West Philly Local; unique monthly visitor estimates for Jewish Exponent based on yearly visitors and for Philadelphia Magazine based on first six months of 2020. The Philadelphia Inquirer fell well below its goal of reducing its workforce by 10% with its latest round of buyouts. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. She was 76. Our searches show that as of August 18, when we began this portion of the data collection, the oldest content included in Factiva for these outlets was published on May 11. Established Mr. Roberts soon asked the managing editor, Gene Foreman no relation to Laura to prepare a comprehensive ethics code, something few newspapers had in that era. Studying the media system in the 1980s and 1990s, Kaniss (1991, 1995) found the citys news outlets chasing after affluent residents retreating to suburban areas.